Boycotting The Clean Plate Club

Posted on November 19th, 2008.

As a young girl, I vividly remember sitting at the kitchen table with my family each night for dinner. I also remember my mother telling us that we couldn’t leave the table until our plates were cleared. In her sweet and enticing “mommy voice” she would cheerfully praise any of us kids who actually did eat everything on our plate. She would say, “Oh my goodness! Look at that! Gina belongs to the Clean Plate Club! Lizzie, don’t YOU want to be part of the Clean Plate Club too?” Of course, I always strived to be an angel child that my parents could be proud of, so I would go ahead and (very reluctantly) eat the rest of my dinner. 

 

There’s also the famous line that my dad would tell us kids when we didn’t want to finish our dinner. He would say, “You need to eat up all of your food because there are kids in Ethiopia who are starving!” 

 

Okay, um, that never really made sense to me. How is it, that ME eating my dinner, is going to help the starving kids in Ethiopia? I mean, it’s awful that there are starving kids in the world… and I really do feel bad that they are in such unfortunate circumstances… but if I stuff myself to an uncomfortable state of fullness, am I really helping them in any way? Unfortunately, no. Not only does that NOT help the starving children in the world, but it actually ends ups hurting me because I am beginning to ignore the signals my body is giving me! 

 

hummus sandwich

 

I realize that my parents had the best of intentions when they said these things to us. They didn’t want us to be wasteful. They wanted us to be grateful for the blessings we’d been given. They wanted to make sure we were all nourished and fed well. However, when the stomach has sent the message to the brain that it’s satisfied and then that body signal is ignored, (just to please mom or dad), you begin to lose touch with what your body is trying to tell you! You are not honoring your fullness signals anymore… and when you do that, you slowly train yourself to become an overeater.  

 

As we aim to live a healthy life or to achieve a physical state that we feel comfortable with, it is imperative that we pay close attention to what our body is telling us! We have to forget about belonging to the “Clean Plate Club” and instead get membership in the “I’m-feeling-satisfied-now-so-I’m-going-to-stop-eating” club. You should NEVER feel guilty when you don’t finish everything on your plate! Instead, you should feel happy that you are in tune with your body and can sense when enough is enough! 

 

After eating a meal, if you often feel stuffed and uncomfortable, you are not paying attention to what your body is telling you! Food is simply a source of energy for us. If you eat TOO much food, what happens? Do you feel ready to get going and take on a big project? Heck no! Here’s a perfect example: How do you usually feel after eating a big fancy feast for Thanksgiving Dinner? How about… unzipping your pants and plopping down on the couch to take a long snooze?! This is NOT how you should feel! Make it a priority to become more aware of how your stomach feels. Base your decision to eat or not eat, on THAT fact and that fact alone! You shouldn’t eat based on whether or not your plate is clean. If you become full and there is still food waiting to be eaten, just save it for later… or {GASP} throw it in the trash! {My mother would be so disappointed if she knew I said that!}

 

Now that I’m a mom and have two kids of my own to care for, you can be sure that I don’t teach them that it’s cool to be part of the “Clean Plate Club”.  I give them a small amount of food on their plate each time we sit down for a meal. I don’t overload their plate and expect them to eat it all. If they finish everything on their plate and still want more, they know they can have it. However, if they tell me they are full and can’t finish their meal, the last thing I do is punish them by insisting that they eat it. {Of course if they tell me they are full – and can’t finish their veggies – yet still have room for a big bowl of ice cream, I know they are tricking me!} With kids, you have to trust them but still use some wise parenting skills. 

 

But with yourself, YOU and only YOU can know exactly how you feel! Obey your body signals to eat or not to eat and by doing so, you will achieve a healthy weight and feel energetic and vibrant! Believe me when I say that it is NOT cool to be part of the “Clean Plate Club!” Boycott that club… and get rid of the mentality that you need to eat everything that’s in front of you, just so you can make someone else happy. 

 

I want to hear what YOU think! Have you experienced this same thing? Do you feel like you have lost touch with your internal signals that tell you when to eat and when to stop? I’d love to get your comments about this subject.

 

Popularity: 33% [?]

Make a Comment

Make A Comment: ( 13 so far )

blockquote and a tags work here.

CommentLuv Enabled

13 Responses to “Boycotting The Clean Plate Club”

RSS Feed for Liz Rosenbaum Fitness Comments RSS Feed

Oh, absolutely! I envy they way my kids just stop eating when they’re full – even while I want to continue eating.

We don’t clean plates here either. We do make our kids eat a certain amount (literally a couple of bites) of whatever is on their plates. They’re picky eaters, and sometimes it’s the only way to get them to try new foods or to develop an appreciation for a flavor. But clean plates? Uh-uh!

cathy
November 19th, 2008

I remember as a kid my parents said the same thing to me. It’s was the starving children in Africa! But I can tell you, that our serving sizes growing were much smaller than what we tend to have today. Right at this moment, I still feel stuffed from lunch because I ate fast and consumed the entire sandwich. If I ate slower and listened to my body, I would have wrapped the other half and saved it for tomorrow. Thanks for the healthy reminder!

Debbie Petrass last blog post..Give Quick Feedback

Debbie Petras
November 19th, 2008

Cathy – I completely agree with you about being envious of children and how intuitive eating comes so naturally to them! It takes hard work and effort for us adults to get back to our intuitive eating.
Debbie – you are RIGHT about serving sizes being enormous these days compared to when we were kids. It’s ridiculous!

Liz Rosenbaum
November 19th, 2008

Great tips I found today for next week’s BIG meal!! I know they will help me!
Krista
. DO eat normally during the day. If you starve yourself, you’ll eat way too much at dinner (an empty stomach often leads to overdoing it), and you’ll probably go for the really bad stuff. So feed your head!

2. DON’T go straight for the dark meat. The lean, white meat turkey is where you’ll get the most bang for your calorie buck. Dark meat has about 15% more calories and 30 – 40% more fat than light meat. And pull off that fatty skin while you’re at it.

3. DO drink lots of water throughout the day AND during the big meal. If you’re hydrated, you’ll be less likely to make bad food choices. Plus it’ll help you fill up faster.

4. DON’T deprive yourself of your favorite things. You know, the ones you dream of all year! If you skimp at the big meal, you could end up recklessly raiding the fridge for leftovers at midnight. Treat yourself, but just be smart about it.

5. DO start with a salad and/or some soup, and then fill your plate mostly with healthy sides and lots of lean meat. By the time you’re done with that serving, you’ll probably be too full to do serious damage with the more fattening extras.

6. DON’T bail on your regular workout routine just because it’s a holiday, especially if you’ve got the day off. You’re going to need that metabolism boost later. Can’t squeeze in a whole workout? Just do SOMETHING, like take a brisk walk or volunteer to play with that hyper kid who’s always making everyone crazy during dinner. (Note: Anyone spending the day cooking a whole feast is exempt!)

7. DO contribute to the meal! Bring along a guilt-free dish of your own, so you know at least one side that’s safe to splurge on. Don’t feel like cooking? Throw together a fresh fruit salad or just steam some veggies and drizzle ‘em with low-cal vinaigrette. Mmmm, easy!

Krista
November 20th, 2008

♥ I love this post ☺ I will gladly boycott this as well. ♥ OH..and I know my Mom would GASP if she saw that we should actually throw something away.
☺☺☺☺☺☺☺☺☺

Krista
November 20th, 2008

Great post. Our first baby comes in March and my wife and I have talked about this. We want to teach our kids good eating habits. Thanks for the great tips and insights.

Blakes last blog post..Haiku Friday and Other Stuff to Read

Blake
November 21st, 2008

Thanks for the reminders.

In my youth it was people are starving in China.
Eating slowly helps also.

James Hubbard, M.D., M.P.H.s last blog post..Potassium may lower blood pressure naturally

James Hubbard, M.D., M.P.H.
November 21st, 2008

Krista – Those are AWESOME bits of advice! I may just have to include those in a post! And Blake, that’s awesome that you and your wife have already discussed how you are going to handle the “eating” situation with your kids. :) Way to plan ahead! And thanks for the comments Dr. Hubbard. Isnt’ it funny how all of our parents used different countries but kept the same message! Eat because others are starving!

Liz Rosenbaum
November 21st, 2008

Being that I believe vegetables are a very important part of our diet – we stress to our kids that before they can have seconds of anything – they must eat their vegetables. And the cool thing – they’ve accepted this. We don’t force large amounts of vegetables at them – and we mix it up. And they’ve become very fine with this. And, as a testament to eating healthy – we have three kids – and all of them are in excellent physical condition. And that attributed to a combination of eating healthy and exercise – two things we stress.

I think it also applies to us as adults. Do we sometimes eat too much? I do. And then I feel “bad” later – bad as in, over full, or generally lethargic. And who wants to feel that way?

Lances last blog post..Sunday Thought For The Day

Lance
November 23rd, 2008

Hey Liz are your parents and my parents related by any chance? Or maybe they just founded the same club! ha ha :)

Take care,
Andrew

Discipline or Regret
November 23rd, 2008

I am trying to teach myself the eat till satisfied thing. I know I feel much better leaving the table before I am full.

Jens last blog post..Back on Track

Jen
November 24th, 2008

Oh, completely! And being a mom and eating in SPURTS, when im NOT cleaning uo food off the floor, serving everyone else, getting up for someone else because they need this or that- i ignore what my body says and kinda go into survival mode… i just eat blindly, because i don’t have the luxery of eating a whole meal beging to end… lol
gotta love our kiddo’s!!
i need to be more aware! thanks for the advice!!!

Annie
November 24th, 2008

My dad alway’s said those sayings. I felt the same way! I don’t pressure my kids into this eithier. I’m lucky because my kids Like fruits and vegtables. Not 100% of course but they do like most of them and they will take a apple anyday over sugar! Yeaahhh! It makes me so proud as a mother.

Gigi Evans
April 8th, 2009

Where's The Comment Form?

Subscribe

Popular Posts

Meta

Topics

Archives

Recent Comments

  • Jenna @ Healthy. Happy. Well.: Hey girl! Love the site. I have yet to try out the shoes but I’ve heard great...
  • Lori: I was so skeptical about these shoes but yet intrigued. You made me want to run out (no pun intended) and get...
  • Liz Rosenbaum: Oh Lance… that’s CLASSIC! And I’m gonna plead the fifth on your question there! I...
  • Lance: Hey Liz, Very fun review!! (i.e. I think you should do more reviews!) And I laughed…about your *ahem*...
  • Ksea: I found that these shoes run 1/2 size small for me. I loved the first pair I had and I am now on a second pair....

 

Liked it here?
Why not try sites on the blogroll...